We're here to help!

Let’s start by finding your agent:

agent contact book in black

Not sure who your agent is?

Almost all Firefly customers have a local agent nearby that provides their service. Not sure who your agent is? Find them using live chat on this page, or with this link. 

agent headset icon in black

Your Agent is our Internal Service Team

A few agents have retired or moved their service to our central office with Jaime, Sandi, Mindy, and Melanie.

Customers of the Griffioens, Jones Insurance-Bob Wise, and others, see below.

bank icon in black

Mortgage or Bank Inquiries

Customer Experience Logo

YOU MATTER TO US

We give our customers the best possible experience while working together as a team. Humor and compassion are part of our interaction with one another and with our customers.

We pride ourselves in being timely, efficient and focusing on the fine details of our work.

And we are here to help YOU!

WE ARE YOUR SERVICE TEAM:

Sandi Headshot

Sandi
Customer Service
I love spending my time with my husband and our family, our 2 wonderful dogs, baking, cars, and DIY home projects!

Mindy Headshot

Mindy
Customer Service
I love spending time with my husband & our two children. I enjoy attending PSU football games and traveling to Florida as often as possible!

Melanie Headshot

Melanie
Customer Service
I love spending time with my husband, kids, and 3 grandkids. I also enjoy painting, dancing, gardening, and our horses, dogs, and cats!

Jane Headshot

Jane
Traffic Coordinator
My husband and I have two sons, four grandchildren, and a loveable tom cat named Ernie. We love to spend time with our family and travel.

Mirannda Headshot

Mirannda
Customer Service
I love spending time with my husband, our cat Waverlee and my family. I also enjoy reading, cooking, and signing!

YOU CAN USE ANY OF THESE OPTIONS TO GET HELP:

Need to file a claim?

You get the fastest help by reporting your claim directly to your insurer.

Click to find your company’s claims phone number.

Policy self-service

Click here to do things like:

Get an auto insurance ID card
Request a change to your policy
See and review your current coverages
And more!

Email

Send an email to all of us at once using this webform and we’ll respond promptly.

Call or text us at (614) 829-8242

This number reaches all of us, and the first available will help you.

Chat with us, below

The chat will ask a couple of questions to get you to the right person, and we’ll take it from there.

Schedule a time to talk with us

Choose a date and time using our easy scheduling page.

Get a Quote

Run your own home, car, and life insurance quotes right here!